I recently watched the original unaired first episode (which is being referred to erringly by the general public, including myself, as the “pilot”) of Dollhouse and it only made me disappointed. To me it felt more like a Joss Whedon production than any “actual” episode of the series. The disappointment was mostly because the it was really smart and well-written, addressing a lot of questions that I had while watching the whole first season. It started character development in motion that just completed stagnated for almost the entire rest of the show. I believe if that episode had aired first I would have been in a much better position to appreciate what came later.
The disappointment also had to do with my (increasingly) poor opinion of the “average viewer.” Or perhaps this poor opinion is better directed toward the Fox Network, or television networks in general and the way they handle content. The reason the first episode of the show was scrapped was reported to be that test audiences found it “too confusing and dark.” This baffled me, because although the first episode was very dialogue-heavy and had a lot of heavy themes (but also a lot of strong feminist themes), I found it very straightforward and a great introduction to the main characters and the world.
The episode it was replaced by, in contrast, was felt rushed and jumbled and had more than one long unnecessary-feeling action sequences with lots of guns and explosions. It was also, in no way, less dark, the main plot of it being that Echo is programmed to negotiate with a serial kidnapper and rapist who sexually abused the woman who her personality was modeled after. But this all falls in line with our general values in movies and television, in which guns, explosions and violence against women are all PG-13, but we get offended if you make us think.
So Candice and I decided to watch the first episode of season 2 on Hulu, because it was easily available and because I was bolstered by having watched the original first episode into thinking that maybe the show could turn itself around. Well, the long and short of it is that I am not going to bother for a while, perhaps ever. The first episode of season 2 had a certain amount of attempted character development, shoved in alongside an Echo-Ballard plot that was just incredibly dull. The Topher/Saunders scene was somewhat interesting, but it felt like they were trying to cram a seasons-worth of development for two characters into one scene. It just didn’t work for me.
Bleh.